Investigation of ancient DNA to enhance natural history museum collections: misidentification of smooth-coated otter (Lutrogale perspicillata) specimens across multiple museums

Authors

  • Filippo Barbanera Department of Biology, Zoology-Anthropology Unit, Via A. Volta 4 - 56126 Pisa
  • Beatrice Moretti Department of Biology, Zoology-Anthropology Unit, Via A. Volta 4 - 56126 Pisa
  • Monica Guerrini Department of Biology, Zoology-Anthropology Unit, Via A. Volta 4 - 56126 Pisa
  • Omar F. Al-Sheikhly Department of Biology, University of Baghdad, Al-Jadriya - 10071 Baghdad
  • Giovanni Forcina Department of Biology, Zoology-Anthropology Unit, Via A. Volta 4 - 56126 Pisa

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.26496/bjz.2016.45

Keywords:

error, genetic identity, mistaken cataloguing, mitochondrial DNA, specimen label

Abstract

Historical and modern natural museum collections are storehouses of extraordinary value for scientific research in a wide range of fields. Recent advances in molecular biotechnology (e.g., next generation genomics) have increased the range of collection material employable for DNA-based analyses to unprecedented levels. Nevertheless, the value of museum specimens strictly depends on reliability of data associated with them. We report on investigations of ancient DNA from specimens of smooth-coated otter (Lutrogale perspicillata, Mustelidae), the largest otter species living in Asia, in US and European mammal collections. Mitochondrial DNA Cytochrome-b gene sequencing proved that the studied specimens were not the expected taxon. Indeed, they actually belonged to three different species, namely the Asian small-clawed (Aonyx cinereus), Eurasian (Lutra lutra) and African clawless (Aonyx capensis) otters. This represents the first record of mustelid misidentification from museum collections. Detection of errors can be extremely difficult when based only on collectors’ notes and data. Hence, we warn scientists involved in otter research about potential challenges when dealing with museum specimens. We recommend curators pursue a multidisciplinary approach, including DNA analyses, to accurately catalogue the resources under their management and uphold the value of biodiversity information.

References

Al-Sheikhly OF, Mukhtar KH, Barbanera F, Csorba G & Harrison DL (2015a). Checklist of the Mammals of Iraq (Chordata: Mammalia). Bonn zoological Bulletin, 64: 33-58.

Al-Sheikhly OF, Mukhtar KH & Barbanera F (2015b). Recent sighting of smooth-coated otter Lutrogale perspicillata maxwelli in Hawizeh marsh (southern Iraq). IUCN Otter Specialist Group Bulletin, 32: 30-32.

Al-Sheikhly OF & Nader AI (2013). The status of Iraq Smooth-Coated Otter Lutrogale perspicillata maxwelli Hayman 1956 and Eurasian otter Lutra lutra Linnaeus 1758 in Iraq. IUCN Otter Specialist Group Bulletin, 30: 18-30.

Barnett R, Yamaguchi N, Shapiro B & Nijman V (2007). Using ancient DNA techniques to identify the origin of unprovenanced museum specimens, as illustrated by the identification of a 19th century lion from Amsterdam. Contributions to Zoology, 76: 87-94.

Bi K, Linderoth T, Vanderpool D, Good JM, Nielsen R & Moritz C (2013). Unlocking the vault: next generation museum population genomics. Molecular Ecology 22, 6018-6032.

Boessenkool S, Star B, Scofield RP, Seddon PJ & Waters JM (2010). Lost in translation or deliberate falsification? Genetic analyses reveal erroneous museum data for historic penguin specimens. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 277: 1057-1064.

de Moraes Barros N, Silva JAB & Morgante JS (2011). Morphology, molecular phylogeny, and taxonomic inconsistencies in the study of Bradypus sloths (Pilosa: Bradypodidae). Journal of Mammalogy, 92: 86-100.

Forcina G, Guerrini M, van Grouw H, Gupta BK, Panayides P, Hadjigerou P, Al-Sheikhly OF, Awan MN, Khan AA, Zeder MA & Barbanera F (2015). Impacts of biological globalization in the Mediterranean: Unveiling the deep history of human mediated game bird dispersal. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the Unites States of America, 112: 3296-3301.

Gee H (1988). Natural History Museum to build DNA database in London. Nature, 336: 707.

Graves GR & Braun MJ (1992). Museums: Storehouses of DNA? Science, 255: 1335-1336.

Guindon S, Dufayard JF, Lefort V, Anisimova M, Hordijk W & Gascuel O (2010). New algorithms and methods to estimate maximum-likelihood phylogenies: assessing the performance of PhyML Systematic Biology, 59: 307-321.

Hall TA (1999). BioEdit: a user-friendly biological sequence alignment editor and analysis program for Windows 95⁄98⁄NT. Nucleic Acids Symposium Series, 41: 95-98.

Harrison DL & Bates PJJ (1991). The Mammals of Arabia. Harrison Zoological Museum, Sevenoaks, Kent, UK.

Higuchi R, Bowman B, Freiberger M, Ryder OA & Wilson AC (1984). DNA sequences from the quagga, an extinct member of the horse family. Nature, 312: 282-284.

Hussain SA, de Silva PK & Mostafa Feeroz M (2008). Lutrogale perspicillata. The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species. Version 2014.3. Downloaded on 14 March 2015, www.iucnredlist.org.

Hwang YT & Larivière S (2005). Lutrogale perspicillata. Mammalian Species, 786: 1-4.

Koblik EA, Red’kin YA, Meer MS, Derelle R, Golenkina SA, Kondrashov FA & Arkhipov VY (2011). Acrocephalus orinus: A Case of Mistaken Identity. PLoS One, 6: e17716.

Koepfli K-P, Kanchanasaka B, Sasaki H et al. (2008a). Establishing the foundation for an applied molecular taxonomy of otters in Southeast Asia. Conservation Genetics, 9: 1589-1604.

Koepfli K-P, Deere KA, Slater GJ et al. (2008b). Multigene phylogeny of the Mustelidae: resolving relationships, tempo and biogeographic history of a mammalian adaptive radiation. BioMed Central Biology, 6:10.

Lee PM, Griffiths R (2003). Sexing errors among museum skins of a sexually monomorphic bird, the Moorhen Gallinula chloropus. Ibis, 145: 695-698.

Lerone L, Mengoni C, Carpaneto GM, Randi E & Loy A (2014). Procedures to genotype problematic non-invasive otter (Lutra lutra) samples. Acta Theriologica, 59: 511-520.

Lister AM, Climate Change Research Group (2011). Natural history collections as sources of long-term datasets (2011). TRENDS in Ecology and Evolution, 26: 153-154.

Lopez J, Yuhki N, Masuda R, Modi W & O’Brien SJ (1994). Numt, a recent transfer and tandem amplification of mitochondrial DNA to the nuclear genome of the domestic cat. Journal of Molecular Evolution, 39:174-190.

Müller L, Gonçalves GL, Cordeiro-Estrela P, Marinho JR, Althoff SL, Testoni AF, González EM & Freitas TRO (2013). DNA Barcoding of Sigmodontine Rodents: Identifying Wildlife Reservoirs of Zoonoses. PLoS One, 8: e80282.

Pääbo S, Gifford JA & Wilson AC (1988). Mitochondrial DNA sequences from a 7000-year old brain. Nucleic Acids Research, 16: 9775-9787.

Pääbo S, Wayne R & Thomas R (1992). On the use of museum collections for molecular genetic studies. Ancient DNA Newsletter, 1: 4-5.

Pergams ORW & Lacy RC (2008). Rapid morphological and genetic change in Chicago-area Peromyscus. Molecular Ecology, 17: 450-463.

Rasmussen PC & Prŷs-Jones RP (2003). History vs mystery: The reliability of museum specimen data. Bulletin of The British Ornithologists’ Club, 123A: 66-94.

Rawlence NJ, Kennedy M, Waters JM & Scofield RP (2014). Morphological and ancient DNA analyses reveal inaccurate labels on two of Buller’s bird specimens. Journal of the Royal Society of New Zealand, 44: 163-169.

Robins JH, Tintinger V, Aplin KP, Hingston M, Matisoo-Smith E, Penny D & Lavery SD (2014). Phylogenetic species identification in Rattus highlights rapid radiation and morphological similarity of New Guinean species. PLoS One, 9: e98002.

Stuart BL & Fritz U (2008). Historical DNA from museum type specimens clarifies diversity of Asian leaf turtles (Cyclemys). Biological Journal of the Linnean Society, 94: 131-141.

Suarez AW & Tsutsui ND (2004). The Value of Museum Collections for Research and Society. BioScience, 54: 66-74.

Tamura K & Nei M (1993). Estimation of the number of the nucleotide substitutions in the control region of mitochondrial DNA in humans and chimpanzees. Molecular Biology and Evolution, 10: 512-526.

Tamura K, Peterson D, Peterson N, Stecher G, Nei M & Kumar S (2011). mega5: Molecular Evolutionary Genetics Analysis using Maximum Likelihood, Evolutionary Distance, and Maximum Parsimony Methods. Molecular Biology and Evolution, 28: 2731-2739.

Thomas RH (1994). Analysis of DNA from natural history museum collections. Molecular Ecology and Evolution: Approaches and Applications, 69: 311-321.

Thomas RH, Schaffner W, Wilson AC & Pääbo S (1989). DNA phylogeny of the extinct marsupial wolf. Nature, 340: 465-467.

Thompson JD, Gibson TJ, Plewniak F, Jean-mougin F & Higgins DG (1997). The ClustalX windows interface: Flexible strategies for multiple sequence alignment aided by quality analysis tools. Nucleic Acids Research, 24: 4876-4882.

Vianna JA, Medina-Vogel G, Chehebar C, Sielfeld W, Olavarría C & Faugeron S (2011). Phylogeography of the Patagonian otter Lontra provocax: adaptive divergence to marine habitat or signature of southern glacial refugia? BioMed Central Evolutionary Biology, 11: 53.

Wandeler P, Hoeck PEA & Lukas FK (2007). Back to the future: museum specimens in population genetics. TRENDS in Ecology and Evolution, 22: 634-642.

Wescheler L (1995). Mr. Wilson’s Cabinet of Wonders. Vintage Books, New York, USA.

Yoxon P & Yoxon GM (2014). Otters of the world. Whittles Publishing, Dunbeath, UK.

Downloads

Published

2020-01-13

How to Cite

Barbanera, F., Moretti, B., Guerrini, M., Al-Sheikhly, O. F., & Forcina, G. (2020). Investigation of ancient DNA to enhance natural history museum collections: misidentification of smooth-coated otter (Lutrogale perspicillata) specimens across multiple museums. Belgian Journal of Zoology, 146(2). https://doi.org/10.26496/bjz.2016.45

Issue

Vol. 146 No. 2 (2016)

Section

Articles

License

All published papers will be put on-line as high resolution PDF’s. Copyright thus remains with the authors. All manuscripts will be licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.